ComparisonSmart scales
Withings Body Smart vs Withings Body Comp: which one should you buy?
Withings Body Smart or Withings Body Comp? The buy-or-skip call in one line, then the differences that actually change your…
Smart bathroom scales compared on accuracy, body composition and app syncing.

ComparisonSmart scales
Withings Body Smart or Withings Body Comp? The buy-or-skip call in one line, then the differences that actually change your…
ComparisonSmart scales
Withings Body Comp or Withings Body+? The buy-or-skip call in one line, then the differences that actually change your day-to-day…
ComparisonSmart scales
Withings Body Comp or Etekcity Smart Fitness Scale? The buy-or-skip call in one line, then the differences that actually change…
ComparisonSmart scales
Withings Body+ or Eufy Smart Scale C1? The buy-or-skip call in one line, then the differences that actually change your…
Best ListSmart scales
Smart bathroom scales compared on accuracy, body composition and app syncing.
Top pickWithings Body Smart
ReviewSmart scales
Should you buy the Fitbit Aria Air? Our buy-or-skip verdict, who it suits, who should skip it and what to…
VerdictConsider $49
ReviewSmart scales
Should you buy the Withings Body Smart Advanced? Our buy-or-skip verdict, who it suits, who should skip it and what…
VerdictConsider $129–$149
ReviewSmart scales
Should you buy the Etekcity Smart Fitness Scale? Our buy-or-skip verdict, who it suits, who should skip it and what…
VerdictBuy $19–$29
Every product with its verdict. Buy picks first.

Etekcity · Smart scales
Buy it if you want basic tracking for very little.
Pros
Cons

Eufy · Smart scales
Buy it if you want a cheap scale with an app.
Pros
Cons

Eufy · Smart scales
Buy it if you want a Wi-Fi scale for the whole family.
Pros
Cons

RENPHO · Smart scales
Buy it if you want basic tracking for very little.
Pros
Cons

Withings · Smart scales
Buy it if you want detailed health metrics.
Pros
Cons

Withings · Smart scales
Buy it if you want reliable trends that sync to Apple Health or Google.
Pros
Cons

Withings · Smart scales
Buy it if you want Wi-Fi sync and body fat tracking.
Pros
Cons

Fitbit · Smart scales
Buy it if you track everything in Fitbit.
Pros
Cons

Garmin · Smart scales
Buy it if you use Garmin watches.
Pros
Cons

Withings · Smart scales
Buy it if you want the most detailed health data at home.
Pros
Cons

Withings · Smart scales
Buy it if you want heart rate in your weigh-ins.
Pros
Cons

Qardio · Smart scales
Buy it if you want pregnancy tracking features.
Pros
Cons
See more Smart scales on Amazon Paid link
ComparisonSmart scales
Withings Body Smart or Withings Body Comp? The buy-or-skip call in one line, then the differences that actually change your…
ComparisonSmart scales
Withings Body Comp or Withings Body+? The buy-or-skip call in one line, then the differences that actually change your day-to-day…
ComparisonSmart scales
Withings Body Comp or Etekcity Smart Fitness Scale? The buy-or-skip call in one line, then the differences that actually change…
ComparisonSmart scales
Withings Body+ or Eufy Smart Scale C1? The buy-or-skip call in one line, then the differences that actually change your…
Best ListSmart scales
Smart bathroom scales compared on accuracy, body composition and app syncing.
Top pickWithings Body Smart
ReviewSmart scales
Should you buy the Withings Body Comp? Our buy-or-skip verdict, who it suits, who should skip it and what to…
VerdictBuy $199
ReviewSmart scales
Should you buy the Withings Body+? Our buy-or-skip verdict, who it suits, who should skip it and what to buy…
VerdictBuy $99
ReviewSmart scales
Should you buy the Garmin Index S2? Our buy-or-skip verdict, who it suits, who should skip it and what to…
VerdictConsider $149
ReviewSmart scales
Should you buy the Eufy Smart Scale C1? Our buy-or-skip verdict, who it suits, who should skip it and what…
VerdictBuy $25–$29
ReviewSmart scales
Should you buy the Fitbit Aria Air? Our buy-or-skip verdict, who it suits, who should skip it and what to…
VerdictConsider $49
Shopping for smart scales on Amazon.com? This hub collects every model Buyrskip has checked and sorts them the only way that matters: buy it, or skip it. 7 of the 12 models here earn a straight buy; the rest are worth considering only in some homes. Smart bathroom scales compared on accuracy, body composition and app syncing.
Weight is accurate on most; body fat numbers are estimates. Syncing with Apple Health or Google Health Connect keeps data in one place. Multiple users: check how many profiles the scale recognizes.
Start with the Withings Body Smart: accurate weight and body composition with great app integration. The RENPHO Elis 1 is the better buy if you want basic tracking for very little. Usual prices run from $19 to $399. See the full buy-or-skip list or the head-to-head Withings Body Smart vs RENPHO Elis 1.
Weigh yourself at the same time each day on a hard floor for consistent trends. Prices on Amazon.com move in a pattern. The deepest cuts land on Prime Day in July, Prime Big Deal Days in October and the Black Friday to Cyber Monday week, with smaller drops around Presidents Day, Memorial Day, the Fourth of July and back-to-school. Judge a deal against the usual price we show, never against the crossed-out list price.
Are body fat readings accurate? They are estimates; track the trend over weeks. Can I use one with a pacemaker? Use weight-only mode; the small current for body composition is not advised with implants or during pregnancy.
Order from Amazon itself or the brand's official storefront so the US manufacturer warranty applies, keep your order confirmation and register the product with the brand. Most items can be returned within 30 days, and holiday purchases often get an extended return window into January.
How we make the call: we read spec sheets, manuals and warranty terms, check long-term owner feedback and US support, and track the usual Amazon.com price. A product gets “Buy” only if we would tell a friend to buy it at that price. Brands cannot pay for a verdict.
↑↓ moveEnter open/ search from anywhere