
Our verdict on the Garmin Index S2
- Buy it if
- you use Garmin watches.
- Skip it if
- you use Apple Health.
- Best for
- Garmin users
- Key feature
- Wi-Fi scale that syncs to Garmin Connect
- Typical price
- $149
Key specifications
| Measures | Weight, body comp |
|---|---|
| Connectivity | Wi-Fi |
| Users | 16 |
| App sync | Garmin Connect |
Who should buy it, and who should skip it
A good fit if you
- you use Garmin watches
- value garmin sync
- can spend around $149
Skip it if you
- you use Apple Health
- mind this: pricey
- mind this: garmin-focused
Pros and cons
Pros
- Garmin sync
- Color screen
- Wi-Fi
- Multiple users
Cons
- Pricey
- Garmin-focused
The verdict in one breath
The Garmin Index S2 is a good smart scale for the right buyer, not an automatic pick. Its strength: wi-Fi scale that syncs to Garmin Connect. Check the skip-if line before you order.
Reasons to buy
- Garmin sync
- Color screen
- Wi-Fi
- Multiple users
Reasons to skip
- Pricey
- Garmin-focused
The specs that matter
- Measures: Weight, body comp
- Connectivity: Wi-Fi
- Users: 16
- App sync: Garmin Connect
Worth knowing
Keeps weight and training data in one app.
Buy it or skip it?
Consider it if you use Garmin watches. Skip it if you use Apple Health; the Withings Body Smart is the better buy then. Everything else is in our list of the best smart scales.
Alternatives worth considering

Withings · Smart scales
Withings Body Smart
Buy it if you want reliable trends that sync to Apple Health or Google.
- Verdict
- Buy
- Best for
- Most people
- Typical price
- $99–$129
Pros
- Accurate
- Great app
Cons
- Pricier

Withings · Smart scales
Withings Body Comp
Buy it if you want detailed health metrics.
- Verdict
- Buy
- Best for
- Detailed health
- Typical price
- $199
Pros
- Detailed metrics
- Wi-Fi sync
Cons
- Pricey
Frequently asked questions
Should I buy the Garmin Index S2?
Consider it, if you use Garmin watches. Why: wi-Fi scale that syncs to Garmin Connect. The catch: pricey.
When should I skip it?
Skip it if you use Apple Health. The Withings Body Smart is the better buy then.
What does the Garmin Index S2 cost?
Usually $149 on Amazon.com. It tends to dip during Prime Day and Black Friday.